Transcript 0:01 [upbeat music] Hey, everyone. 0:41 Welcome to episode 51 of the Slice of Healthcare podcast. I'm your host, Jared Taylor. On today's episode, we have Nathaniel Fabis, hopefully I didn't butcher that name [laughs], the CEO of Halo Doctor. 0:58 Let's not waste any time. Let's bring him on. [upbeat music] Thanks so much for, for joining me on the Slice of Healthcare podcast. How are you today? Really good. Really good. 1:16 Thanks a lot for inviting me. Yeah. Thanks for being our first international guest. This is, uh, really exciting. Um, I, I learned about your company a while back. 1:26 Obviously, um, you know, telehealth is, has, has been huge here in the States and also globally, especially with everything going on with, with COVID-19. So really excited to have you on the podcast. 1:37 I'd love if you could get started by telling the audience a little bit about yourself, and then we'll go into talking about, uh, Halo Doctor and more of, uh, what, what you've done. Mm-hmm. Well, so I'm Nathaniel. 1:49 I'm the CEO of Halo Doctor. Uh, I'm originally from France, and I first arrived in Indonesia, uh, eight years ago. Uh, I was part of the team who started Lazada, a, a major e-commerce company in the, in the region. 2:00 Uh, and before and after that, I was doing, uh, market research and consulting for pharma companies, uh, in emerging market. 2:07 Uh, so I was working, uh, in Africa and Indonesia to provide more accurate information, uh, about what was going on on the flo- on the ground, uh, to those international pharma companies. 2:18 Uh, in 2014, uh, me and my wife and my co-founder, Suchi, uh, who is Indonesian, uh, we were seeing that people were starting to go more and more online, right? 2:27 So Indonesia is an emerging market, so people started to go on the internet heavily starting in the 2010s. 2:33 And people were going more and more online to look for medical information, and there was a lot of inaccurate medical information back at the time, uh, online. 2:42 So especially I was seeing my wife, Suchi, and her family in-law, uh, taking very, very bad decision, uh, about healthcare based on what they were reading online, and they had no ways offline as well to get access to accurate information. 2:55 So, uh, basically we wanted to solve that and build a, a platform. 2:59 So the first challenge for our company was to build a WebMD, uh, for Indonesia with accurate information and easy information, uh, in local language, in Bahasa Indonesia, uh, so that people can take the right decision, uh, for their care based on what, uh, they were, uh, reading. 3:15 So our, our content platform, article, and video picked up really fast. Uh, we started having millions and millions of user, uh, on the platform. 3:23 Uh, today, halodoctor.com is one of the most read, uh, healthcare website in the world, uh, for, for, for medical content. Uh, something in the top 15, I believe. Uh, 3:33 today we have 31 million, uh, people visiting this platform, uh, on a monthly basis, basically trying to rely on our information, uh, to get accurate information. 3:43 Uh, then o- on top of that, uh, starting in 2016, we decided to build, uh, basically w- what we call in the region a super hub for healthcare, uh, with, [laughs] with, uh, more features. 3:56 So Asia will be very different from, from the West in that regard, that companies would try to explore different verticals at the same time and build an ecosystem into a single app. 4:04 So we started telemedicine in 2016, uh, a little bit similar to Teladoc. 4:09 Uh, today we have, uh, close to 1,000 doctors, uh, active on the platform, and we have one of the most active, uh, telemedicine platform in Asia today. 4:18 We also have a large doctor booking platform, and, uh, we, uh, starting from 2018 as well, we sell our own, uh, private label insurance called Halo Doctor Proteksi, uh, to our consumer, uh, a little bit similar to Oscar in the US. 4:33 So what we're trying to do basically is to be the all-in-one ecosystem, uh, for healthcare, where Indonesian patient can fully manage their health, uh, from prevention, uh, with the content, trying to solve, uh, issues at home, uh, first with telemedicine. 4:46 And if the issue get bigger, uh, book an appointment to a doctor directly from our platform, and all of it, uh, being covered by our insurance policy that you can purchase, uh, directly in Halo Doctor. 4:57 So that's what we do. Interesting. Now, tell... A, a good bit of our audience is based in the US, so if... 5:04 could you briefly tell us, like in the areas that your platform is heavily used, what the kind of health system looks like in those areas? Um, like is there a mixture of... 5:16 Is, is insurance comp- Which insurance companies, um, um, was it mainly private or public in your area? 5:24 So, [clears throat] uh, so if you, if you have to summarize about, uh, the Indonesian medical system today, I mean, it's categorized by a few things, right? 5:31 Uh, number one, I mean, most of the spending is still out of pocket, uh, so it's not insured. So basically, uh, it would be something like, uh, 40% public, uh, insurance, 10% private insurance, and 50% out of pocket. 5:46 Uh, and basically middle class and upper middle class would be the ones that will go to out of pocket, uh, most of the time. 5:54 So very different from more, for example, from, uh, the US where it would be different type of population that would be on the out of pocket, uh, population, right? 6:02 So the lower class, the middle, lower middle class would go in the public system, and the middle class, upper middle class will often go, uh, with out of pocket, uh, spending. 6:12 Uh, today the government's trying to push hard for public, uh, insurance to develop, but there's limitation in terms of budget, uh, that has not been overcome yet, uh, in order to have, uh, most of the population covered, uh, with public system, uh, today. 6:26 Uh, private insurance is very undeveloped yet. Uh, only 2% of Indonesian people have, uh, private insurance, uh, today. 6:34 Uh, so that's, uh, basically one of the reason that we believe as well that what we're doing is so important is that patient have to take so many decisions by themself about their health because they're not covered, right? 6:44 And every decision can end up, uh, into a major, um, financial decision for, for most people, uh, out here when there, there is a, a medical issue. So that's the number one. Number two is, uh, the lack of doctor, right? 6:56 So Indonesia have one of the lowest, uh, doctor per capita, uh, in the world, uh, today. Uh, and the doctor are spread as well unevenly. Uh, and most of the doctors will be in major urban area. 7:09 So when you go in small town, when you go in rural area, there will usually be, uh, very little or absolutely no doctor, right? 7:17 Uh, so that's also something where, uh, access to remote healthcare will become more and more important, is that you have so many area in the country, uh, where it's very hard to access, uh, doctors, uh, on the, 7:29 on the daily basis, or if you have to go see a doctor you may have to travel very far. What, uh, what made you want to, uh, kind of start the insurance arm of the business? What did you see that made you wanna do that? 7:44 Uh, so, so the, the, the, the several reason, right? I mean, the, the first one is that because we, we, we were doing, like, chat doctor booking, right? 7:53 And we are seeing that money was usually the main, uh, the main blocker, right? 7:57 So people had to go for treatment, they had to go see a doctor, and we were discussing with our patients, and they were telling like, "Doctor, doctor, I don't have money to do that. Can I..." Wow. 8:06 So- sometime surgery, and they were telling us, "Can I buy a cheap drug in the pharmacy?" And sometime you can't, right? You need to go for tests, you need to do, uh, stuff. 8:13 And, uh, we were not talking to people that were very poor. I mean, we're talking more about people that are using platform will be more even middle class, right? 8:20 Uh, and money limitation was a huge factor that, uh, that was basically preventing people from getting, uh, proper healthcare. 8:29 And on the same side, we are seeing that insurance company in Indonesia were not that focused on, uh, healthcare. They were more focused on life, uh, insurance where the margins are bigger, right? 8:40 So, uh, at the same time, we are seeing a huge need, right? 98% of population is uninsured, uh, privately, 50% out of pocket. Uh, family drama all the time, right? 8:52 Around us, uh, inside the company, outside the company, more patient. 8:56 And basically the companies that could focus on it, not really focusing on it, uh, because they didn't see it as, uh, basically the major, uh, major focus, right? 9:06 Other thing as well is that we are seeing that the product, uh, that were proposed were not really adapted to the population, right? 9:13 So i- in Indonesia, the trust level will not be as high as what you will have in, in more developed market. Uh, so if you want to convince someone to come and take an insurance, the insurance have to be simple. 9:26 Uh, and we were seeing that the existing policy in the market were extremely complex. 9:31 Uh, and we are discussing with insurance companies, and they were showing me the product they had, and I was like, "Okay, I don't even understand it myself." 9:37 So, uh, when, uh, for example, we have insurance policy for our employee, even myself, when I have to understand it, it takes me 20, 30 minutes to barely understand what we're covering, right? 9:47 So when you are co- in a country where most of the populations pay out of pocket and you want to sell retailer, uh, insurance directly to consumer, you need to take a step back and basically try to make, uh, insurance that is very, very simple. 10:01 That's, uh, second thing. The first thing is that we believe that, uh, uh, the integration of insurance with chat and booking can create, uh, the health experience of the 21st century. 10:13 So what we see from patient is that they are often very confused and lost, not only in Indonesia, but in most places, right? You don't know how to take a decision. You don't know what is the right decision. 10:23 You don't know which doctor to go see, what tests to do, and so forth and so forth. And we believe that, uh, a medical company or an insurance company in the 21st century will have to basically 10:34 not, not try to control, right, but basically support the patient, uh, in every step of the way, right? And by doing it digitally- Yeah... 10:41 uh, with telemedicine, chat, booking, integrated booking, uh, and other integration will be in the future, you can start to basically follow the cu- follow the patient 10:52 all across the journey and basically get to much higher, uh, quality of care that you could have, uh, with traditional systems. So you're basically building a, a whole ecosystem 11:02 of, of everything that the patient would actually really want and need to have, um, to, to, you know, match up with this journey that you just described. Yeah. That's really interesting. 11:13 Um, how, how has COVID-19 affected, uh, your country during everything that's going on? So, uh, i- i- i- in terms of numbers, I mean, the, the... 11:24 if you look at the official numbers and the number of case are, are quite small, right? Uh, if you look at the official numbers, so we don't... But the issue is that the testing capacity are quite small as well, right? 11:35 So there's still a lot of uncertainty about the real spread of the, uh, disease, right? Uh, so we are seeing people not caring too much until the government started to speak a lot about it. 11:46 Uh, and then we had a, a panic, I think like everywhere in the world, right? 11:50 And that gradually, uh, end up into a, almost a full lockdown today, uh, for example, in Jakarta, in most big cities, uh, in, uh, Indonesia, right? 12:00 So let's say the paradox we have is that the countries is in, uh, the country is in almost in a full lockdown today, uh, while we have absolutely no idea about the spread, uh, of, uh, the condition, uh, today, which obviously give a lot of uncertainty as well in how we're going to go get out of, uh, the situation as well. 12:19 If we think about tropical countries, right, there's still like, uh, and hot countries, there's still a lot of uncertainty in how the virus spread. In those area, right? 12:26 Um, if you look at the numbers, there's no hot country in tropical area that is very humid where there's a high number of case. It doesn't mean that the virus is not spreading. 12:36 Uh, maybe all of those countries are not, uh, testing properly, right? So there's a lot of uncertainty about what is really going on, uh, right now in Indonesia. 12:45 Uh, obviously once people started worried, we had a lot, a lot more requests, uh, on our side. 12:50 Uh, our demand on telemedicine, uh, jumped by, uh, uh, almost 100%, uh, on the platform, uh, as people, uh, are asking for more, uh, info, especially for the content. 13:01 We have a peak at plus 100% compared to usual, uh, on, on, on our side. Uh, on the other hand, people are scared to go to the hospital, uh, at the moment. 13:10 So everything that is related to booking our hospital are going down. 13:14 And information we have is that private hospital see their, uh, frequent, uh, see their, uh, number of patients drop by 50% compared to usual, uh, at the moment. 13:24 So the, the big challenge for us was, uh, number one, I mean, uh, making sure that we're providing the right information to all our, our patients, uh, across so many items that you can cover, uh, in terms of content. 13:36 And also training our doctors, uh, to respond properly to this crisis, uh, on our side. We also have a lot of AI, uh, in our telemedicine today. 13:45 So, uh, we build a specific AI as well for the COVID-19 to support the doctor to answer properly, uh, to the, to the, to the crisis. And obviously we had to, uh, scale up very, very fast our telemedicine capacity, right? 14:01 I mean, uh, when you get from overnight, you get plus 100% of demand, uh, you need to scale up. So it's been basically, uh, 14:09 super hectic, uh, months on our side to be able to scale up, uh, our internal capacity, uh, to answer to the demand. What, what type of doctors, um, leverage the platform for telemedicine services? 14:25 So we, we work with GP and with specialists. So both of them, right? So we... And we have all specialty, uh, on our platform. 14:31 So basically, uh, seven days a week, uh, almost 24/7, uh, you can access a doctor and speak with any specialist within two minutes, uh, today. And, uh, 14:42 we are doing more than 600,000 consultation a month, uh, on our platform at the moment. Oh, wow. That's great. Uh, that's really great. What's... 14:54 In the early stages, now, now only what you're willing to share, what was, what was one of the, I guess, challenges in getting this off the ground, in your mind? 15:06 So I mean, the, the, the, the main difficulty of healthcare when you, when you, when you build a startup in healthcare, uh, is, is that e- every, every, every market will be different, right? 15:16 So you have to invent your own model. Uh, you can't really rely on, "Oh, something happened in US, something happened in China. I'm just going to do the same," right? Yeah. 15:24 Uh, which is often what entrepreneurs in emerging market would start at the beginning, and then they change. 15:29 In healthcare from the beginning, you know that you have to figure out on your own, uh, what you're doing, right? So you need to convince a lot of people that what you're doing makes sense, right? 15:36 Uh, you need to convince, uh, your employee, you need to convince your client, you need to convince your partner, you need to convince the government, you need to convince your investors, right? 15:43 So, uh, you cannot be sure by yourself, right? You have to try a lot of things. You have to speak to a lot of people. 15:50 Uh, and you have to figure out your way, uh, basically, uh, on your own, uh, and convince people that you're not just completely nuts, uh, but what you are doing makes, uh, makes sense. 16:00 Uh, and I would say that even as we scale, that's always the, the, the, uh, one of the, the biggest challenge is that what we have to build has to be highly original. 16:08 And when you're highly original, obviously, uh, you are encountering a lot of skepticism about what you do, and you need to prove with, with, uh, result and success, uh, that you're doing the right thing. 16:21 No, that's, that's great. So what, what do you see as... I mean, it, it sounds like you've, since you've started the company, you've added all these different parts to it. Um, 16:31 do you have a, a specific part that you think you'll continue to invest in and really make your, your main part of your ecosystem? Is that telemedicine or is that the kind of the content piece of the platform? 16:43 What would you say is your, kind of your core piece that you're doing? Uh, so, so, uh, it's a good question. I mean, the, the, the... 16:53 Definitely, I mean, we see that this COVID crisis is putting a big highlight on telemedicine. Uh, so telemedicine is here to stay, uh, for sure. 17:02 And that's going to be, uh, one of the backbone, if not the backbone, in the company for, for, for the long run. 17:07 Um, after that, where we think we're going to have the most impact on the long run, uh, on our side is, is on the insurance piece of the business, uh, for, for Indonesia at least, right? Uh, why? 17:17 Because this is the biggest pain point, we believe, for an Indonesian family today. Uh, how to cover your health, how to get the money for your health. 17:24 And that's where as well where we believe that we can buy a field, uh, something very, very special as a, a, a, as a model. 17:30 Uh, basically mixing and integrating, uh, the insurance piece of the business with the telemedicine and, uh, the booking. 17:38 The challenge we have is that we need to scale in the country where people are not able to, are not, are not, uh, uh, used to buy, uh, insurance. 17:45 And we have also to prove to the insurance industry that we can, uh, control claims, um, much better than what they do, uh, in traditional way, uh, so that we can cover more and more and more and more benefit, uh, to Indonesian people, right? 17:58 So our vision, let's say in two, three years, is that, um, if you're Indonesian middle class, 18:03 uh, you pay something like $15 to $20 a month per person, and you can get a proper, uh, medical coverage, uh, even when you get a, a major, uh, medical issue. 18:13 Uh, so basically building very affordable healthcare, very affordable protection. And that could really change the way, uh, most people live their life, uh, in Indonesia, right? 18:24 Uh, I mean, healthcare is very, very high in terms of stress here. Uh, because basically if someone in your family gets sick, you know you can go bankrupt, right? 18:31 And that's really what we want to solve, uh, in the long run, right? Meaning that- You, uh, you spend for your family 80, $100 a month. 18:40 Uh, and you can get a, a basic and proper protection, uh, for most of your need, uh, for healthcare. 18:46 And really that's without technology, without technology integration, uh, with all the vertical we have, it would be impossible to do, right? 18:52 So obviously when I say we focus on insurance, it means that telemedicine is going to be a key part, uh, of it, uh, on the long run. And, uh, basically building this insurance of the 21st century would not be possible, 19:04 uh, without, uh, telemedicine. Wow, okay. No, that's, that's, uh, a great vision. Um, uh, you know, I really look forward to following the company more and, and kind of seeing how full things, you know, come into fold. 19:18 But- Sure... [laughs] you've accomplished so much with the company since inception and, um, I mean, it, it's so exciting what you're working on. 19:26 I, I love this ecosystem that you've created with all these different offerings. And, and how much, I mean, you can't fake this, how much you truly care about the patient too. 19:35 So I, I have to really applaud you for that too. Um, I can tell how passionate you are when you're talking about, you know, creating this better experience for the patient. 19:43 Um, which is cool, and you can create a cool company and do that, which does not always go hand in hand, um, especially in the US. So I really, [laughs] I really like hearing, uh... 19:54 I, I like hearing that you're doing that over there. Um, cool. Yeah, no, this, this is, this is really great. Uh, where, where can people learn more about, I guess, uh, you and, and, uh, the company? Sorry? 20:07 Uh, where can people learn more about you and the company? Uh, so, I mean, I mean, uh, it's true that most, most of our, most of our, uh... most of our communication is in, uh, local language, right? 20:20 But my LinkedIn, I guess, uh, or the company LinkedIn could be a, a great way to learn about, uh, what we're doing or the latest news, uh, of what we are, uh, what we are doing on our side. 20:31 And we may have some big news, uh, coming in, uh, in the next few weeks, uh, on our LinkedIn page. Perfect. Yeah. When I went onto your site, uh, Google automatically translated it for me, so I could pick up most of it. 20:44 [laughs] Um, but, uh, yeah, no, I really like your site, by the way, too. Um, once, once it was translated and I could understand [laughs] what was on the site. 20:54 [laughs] But, um, well, again, I really appreciate you coming on. 20:58 This was great to learn more about yourself and, and what you're building, which is, is truly transformative and, um, much needed, especially during the times that we're in. 21:08 Um, glad to hear you're, you're well and healthy and, um, you know, keep doing these, these huge things. They're, they're really cool. Thanks for inviting me, Jared. It was a real pleasure and, uh, 21:18 uh, hope to hear the podcast as well soon. Yeah. Yeah. Look forward to, uh, for it to go live. Absolutely. Thanks again. Thanks. 21:27 [upbeat music] Hey, everyone. I wanted to give a quick shout-out to our sponsor, Bloc Health. 21:44 Bloc Health is unlocking healthcare professional data, making it easily shareable. 21:49 They want to make life easier for healthcare professionals and organizations so that they can focus on tasks like providing the best care possible to patients. 21:58 Bloc Health leverages their smart, universal common application and blockchain technology 22:04 to streamline many of the tasks that healthcare professionals and organizations must engage in, like primary source verification, provider enrollment, state licensing, state license renewals, DEA registration, DEA renewals, and much more. 22:19 They do all of this through their easy-to-use platform. If you would like to learn more about Bloc Health, please check out their website at www.blochealth.com. Thanks. 22:35 [upbeat music] Thank you to everyone that listened to this week's episode of the Slice of Healthcare podcast. 22:55 If you'd like to check out more of our podcasts, we're available on all the major podcast channels, and you can check us out on our website, www.sliceofhealthcare.com. And that'll have all of our past guests on there. 23:12 Uh, you could see our sponsors, and you can learn more about actually becoming a guest. Thanks, and look forward to another episode next week. 23:23 [upbeat music]